Do you sleep well at night? According to research, more than 100 million Americans aren’t getting the amount of sleep needed to ensure proper health 3. Further research states mattress quality is the biggest cause of poor sleep for those complaining of chronic pain 2. Finding the best mattress for better sleep is not an easy task and requires great due diligence and fortitude. To make things easier, we’ve combed through all our mattress reviews to come up with a list of the best mattress in each category we’ve compared so far.
Links on this page may earn us a small commission when clicked. To learn more read our Affiliate Disclosure.
Table of Contents
Mattress quality has a direct impact on sleep quality and our health
Before we dive into our considerations of the inherent qualities found in the best mattress, let’s first take a moment to consider the importance of sleep. After all—to consider a mattress completely one must understand the many positive effects it may offer. In a 2015 sleep survey, the National Sleep Foundation found that the environmental factors played the largest role in sleep quality. Among these factors, mattress quality was the most important influence on sleep quality1. Second, to mattress quality, the temperature was the next leading environmental factor. This study also revealed that people that sleep well at night report having a 50% better overall state of health and quality of life 1. This suggests that mattresses have a direct influence over our health and wellbeing and that having the highest-quality mattress possible with the best possible temperature control will set us up for success. Simple right? As it turns out, finding the best mattress amidst the ocean of possible options can be quite a task.
Best Mattresses by Category
Memory foam, traditional, latex, you name it—we’ve reviewed it
We’ve reviewed quite a few mattresses and during the process, we’ve had the pleasure of experiencing some truly world-class products. We’ve also had the misfortune of spending a few nights trying to sleep on heaps of springs and heat that epitomize misery. Seriously. From our experience, we’ve realized that an individual’s sleeping preferences largely influence which mattress is best-suited for them. To help you on your search for the best mattress, we’ve organized all our mattress reviews by type of mattress and/or sleep preference. We then selected the best mattress from each category to help narrow your search. Below you’ll find our results.
Best Memory Foam Mattress
Nectar Sleep Memory Foam
Nectar Sleep is one of the fastest-rising stars on the market today and has been giving many so-called ‘big guys’ a run for their money. Their rise in popularity can be attributed to their innovative designs as well as their awareness of market demand. The Nectar Sleep memory foam mattress comes in a 5 layer design which features a broad approach to addressing the needs of the many. This means that Nectar Mattresses are perfect for the vast majority of sleeping styles. Features a TENCEL cooling cover, quilted gel memory foam top layer, regular memory foam layer underneath that, and two more foam layers underneath. Comes with a 365 in home trial, ships for free, and has a LIFETIME warranty.
Best Hybrid Mattress
Tomorrow Sleep Hybrid Memory Foam + Innerspring
Tomorrow Sleep is the new kid on the block though their team has decades of experience within the mattress industry. The Tomorrow Sleep Hybrid Memory Foam + Microcoil mattress design features three separate layers of foam for ideal contour and airflow support. All this rests on a bed of individually-wrapped innerspring coils for extra support and excellent airflow. Tomorrow Sleep mattresses make use of perforated side foam blocks for superior ventilation and edge support. This mattress comes with a 100 in home trial, free shipping, and a 10-year warranty. This mattress is as innovative as it is comfortable and the best all-around hybrid memory foam mattress we’ve reviewed.
Best Luxury Mattress
Saatva Luxury Plush
Saatva is no novice when it comes to designing high-quality mattresses. Their Luxury Plush Hybrid mattress features a deeply padded pillow top which rests on a bed of individually-wrapped coils to provide an incredible system of weight distribution. Saatva offers a 120 night in home trial, a 15-year warranty, but do not currently offer free shipping. These mattresses aren’t considered bed-in-a-box by design, and require delivery by a specialized carrier service which is arranged by Saatva. This mattress sleeps like a luxury mattress and its inclusion or an organic cotton wrapping is just icing on the cake. It’s an incredible mattress but the price makes it an easy pick for best luxury mattress.
Best Firm Mattress
Beautyrest Black Calista
The Serta-Simmons Beautyrest line is one of the most popular lines of mattresses in the world. Recently, they announced their lineup of Beautyrest Black mattresses that have been designed to offer the most luxurious night’s sleep imaginable. The Calista is the entry level mattress in the Beautyrest Black line and is available in a super firm option. This mattress is sleek, well-made, and is the firmest mattress we’ve reviewed by far and we’d describe it as an 8.5-9/10 for firmness. Backed by a Serta-Simmons 10-year limited warranty though shipping and in-home trial periods depend on where you buy from.
Best Plush Mattress
DreamCloud Hybrid Memoryfoam + Innerspring
The DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid offers an eight-layer design meant to address the needs of any sleeper. The top layer features a Truetufted Cashmere blend and embodies the “cloud” aspect of the Dreamcloud name. This mattress also features a layer of microcoils for better overall weight distribution and breathability. Other layers in this mattress include gel-infused memory foam and even a natural latex for a bit of that nice “springy” action. Overall, we’re pretty big fans of this mattress. It’s the best plush mattress we’ve reviewed and strong contender in the luxury mattress category as well. Comes with a lifetime warranty, 365-Night In-Home Trial, and free shipping.
Most Innovative Mattress
Purple Hyper-Elastic Polymer Memory Foam
Purple mattresses may not be considered the best mattresses by everyone out there—but they certainly are the most unique! This mattress features a Hyper-Elastic Polymer material that looks like some form of a futuristic egg carton but offers comfort like an artisan masseuse. Purple’s patented polymer material rests on two lower layers of foam to provide all night support while still promoting adequate airflow. These mattresses come with a 10-year warranty, 100-night warranty and free shipping. This mattress design was inspired from actual rocket science and did we mention that it’s purple?
Best Value Mattress
Green Tea Memory Foam by Zinus
The Green Tea memory foam mattress by Zinus is one of the most affordable mattresses on the market today. It’s received a phenomenal amount of positive reviews (nearly 10K 5 Star Reviews on Amazon alone). This mattress is one of the best mattresses on the market for the under the $300 price range. The Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress features a 12″ thick design consists of 4 unique layers of foam materials—the topmost being a 3″ thick layer of memory foam. This layered design allows the benefits of memory foam while avoiding the majority of heating concerns. CeriPUR certified, ships for free, has a 10-year warranty and comes with a 100-night in-home trial. Our top-pick with affordability as a primary consideration. Great for college students and young professionals.
Best Natural & Organic Mattress
Two-Sided Natural Latex Hybrid by IDLE Sleep
IDLE Sleep is a relative new-comer to the mattress industry but their two-sided luxury latex hybrid bears no marks of their youth. This mattress may be our favorite mattress out of all that we’ve had the chance to review. It features a flippable design with two layers of natural Talalay latex offering a firm comfort level on top and a medium comfort level on the bottom side. Beneath these layers of latex, there rests a layer of microcoils to help reduce motion transfer and promote airflow. All this is wrapped in an organic cotton cover that is incredibly soft. Handmade in the USA, comes with a Lifetime warranty, 120-Night In-Home Trial, and ships for free. Another close contender in the luxury mattress category.
Best Mattress for Hot Sleepers
Amerisleep AS3 (Liberty) Memory Foam
The Amerisleep AS3 is a tremendous example of modern innovation in mattress design. This mattress features four layers of foam designed to maximize the benefits of memory foam while avoiding overheating. The heat-dissipating action of the AS3 is best characterized by the Celliant material used in its outermost layer of fabric. This material has been engineered to actually convert body heat into light which compliments the already breathable design. All things considered, the Amerisleep AS3 is one of the best mattresses around and our top pick for anyone that wants to ensure a cool night’s sleep.
About Our Choices
We aren’t Scientists but we’ve done our research
Our picks for best mattress aren’t to be considered Scientific in nature. We’ve researched each of these mattresses extensively and have considered the attributes we feel to be most relevant for most people. These mattresses have been chosen for their overall value rather than their ability to address any single need. For example, a $2500 memory foam mattress will likely be of higher overall quality than a $600 one but our consideration takes into account both the quality and the price. In other words, if most people can’t afford it we don’t consider it a great mattress.
The mattresses listed here are those we feel best to represent the categories for which they were chosen as the best mattress. We’d like to make special note that when buying a new mattress one’s most immediate choice will be whether to buy a mattress online or to buy one in a local store. Many of the mattresses reviewed here are available in only one of the two. Most bed-in-a-box brands such as Nectar Sleep, Tomorrow Sleep, and Amerisleep only offer their products for sale online. This isn’t the case with every mattress but is a good general rule. For those buying in local stores; it’s now common to receive an in-home trial period during which you can return your mattress for a full refund. If your local mattress store doesn’t offer this—find another one!
National Sleep Foundation. 2015 Sleep in America Poll. Sleep Health, Volume 1, Issue 2, Pages e14-e375. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sleh.2015.02.005
Center for Disease Control. Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System. 2009. Available from: https://www.cdc.gov/features/dssleep/index.html
Ancoli-Israel S, Roth T. Characteristics of insomnia in the United States: results of the 1991 National Sleep Foundation Survey. I. Sleep. 1999 May 1;22 Suppl 2:S347-53. PubMed PMID: 10394606.
How’d We Do?
We try hard to provide useful reviews and buyer’s guides. Let us know how useful you felt this guide is by using the rating box below:
Reader Rating108 Votes4.7
HomeRefinery is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program that helps us earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Links from our website to Amazon.com may earn us a small commission when clicked. To learn more about these types of links read our Affiliate Disclosure